Can a delay in prosecution violate someone’s due process rights?
The police cannot wait forever to charge someone after a crime was allegedly committed. The Statute of Limitations and due process rights protect people from delayed prosecution.
How Long Does the Government Have to Charge a Person with a Crime After it is Committed?
Most people have heard of “statutes of limitations.” These rules govern how long a prosecutor has to charge a state or federal crime, such as a felony or misdemeanor. How long does the government have to charge a person with a felony or misdemeanor? Different time periods apply to different types of cases. In criminal cases, as a general rule, the more serious a matter, the longer the statute of limitations. However, some cases, such as murder, are so serious that there is no statute of limitations.
Examples of some criminal statutes of limitations:
- Murder: No limit
- Conspiracy to Commit Murder: No limit
- Criminal Sexual Conduct 1st Degree: No limit
- Human or Sex Trafficking: 25 years
- Kidnapping: 10 years
- Extortion: 10 years
- Manslaughter: 10 years
- Home Invasion 1st Degree: 10 years
- Identity Theft: 6 years
- Most Other Felonies: 6 years
- All Misdemeanors: 6 years
Does the government have to charge a person within a reasonable time?
Charging a person with a crime is very serious business. However, the law favors having it done as soon as possible so that issues in people’s lives can get resolved, they can move on, and victims of crime can feel like losses they suffered are being made right in their eyes. Both defendants and victims want their “day in court.” Both defendants and victims need to feel like there is a forum to resolve cases.
The law also favors charging a case as soon as possible because the evidence may be lost, deteriorate, or witnesses may die or forget details they once knew over time. Therefore, it is in the interests of justice to bring cases to court as soon as possible so that the best and most reliable evidence can be presented.
“What if the government can’t find me? Can I wait it out until the criminal statute of limitations expires?”
First, the Statute of Limitations covers situations where the government fails to file charges in court promptly and a criminal warrant is not issued for an extended period. The clock stops if the charge is filed in court before the statute of limitations expires. Delay after the charge is filed in court is inapplicable, regardless of the delay before the defendant appears.
Suppose a suspect moves, leaves, or flees the state of Michigan. If someone under investigation leaves Michigan for some time, the statute is “tolled” or stopped. If a suspect stays out of the government’s reach for 10 years in a case with a 6-year statute, they can still be prosecuted because while they were gone, the statute was not running. So even if you’re honestly innocent and had no idea you were being sought, the statute will still be stopped from running while you are gone.
However, an astute and creative attorney would argue that justice would not be served by going forward with the case after so long, and the charges should be dismissed. At the very least, a sharp attorney would argue that you deserve a very lenient plea agreement (assuming you have behaved well while out of the jurisdiction). If the delay is unreasonable, an argument can be made in court to dismiss all charges based on violating your due process rights under the Fifth Amendment. If you wonder, “How long does the government have to charge someone?” and the statute of limitations is not an issue, the Due Process Clause might be used to get charges dismissed.
Reasons for a Delay in Prosecution
The evidence may be very complex in many cases, such as in sizeable financial fraud cases. It takes a long time for the government to collect evidence, analyze it, interview witnesses and experts, and decide on a proper charge they believe they can prove in court. However, even in such cases, the pre-charge investigation should never take longer than the standard statute of six (6) years. The government must be held accountable to that time limit by an aggressive, reputable defense lawyer.
In other cases, the police may have no leads to go on and no evidence of the perpetrator’s identity, and the case goes “cold.” Some of these cases may never end up being charged. Suppose the statute of limitations expires while they are trying to figure it out. In that case, a defense lawyer can file a Motion to Dismiss Charges based on a violation of the criminal statute of limitations.
What to Do if You Believe There May Be Charges Against You
If you have reason to believe there may be charges coming or already filed against you, the wise thing to do is retain a highly experienced criminal defense expert to look into it for you on a precharge basis. If there is a warrant for you, it will never go away. It is always best to confront the charges with a top-notch, respected defense attorney by your side.
The timing of legal representation can significantly alter the course of a case. One strategic approach, often overlooked but immensely beneficial, is hiring a lawyer on a precharge basis, particularly when there is a delay in prosecution. This preemptive step can serve as a powerful defense mechanism, offering numerous advantages. Firstly, it allows for proactive involvement in the investigative phase, potentially influencing the direction and scope of the investigation before charges are formally filed. An experienced lawyer can work diligently to present mitigating evidence or arguments to prosecutors during this critical period, which might lead to a decision not to charge or to charge a lesser offense. Furthermore, early legal counsel helps prepare a robust defense strategy from the outset, ensuring that any evidence obtained or statements made by the accused are done with legal protection in mind. Additionally, this period allows for negotiating bail and release conditions directly, avoiding unnecessary pretrial detention.
Hiring a lawyer before charges are filed also demonstrates to the prosecuting authority the seriousness with which the accused is taking the allegations, possibly affecting their charging decisions. In essence, engaging a criminal defense lawyer during a delay in prosecution not only safeguards one’s rights from the very beginning but also positions the case favorably, potentially mitigating the legal repercussions that might follow. LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C., with its seasoned team of defense attorneys, stands ready to offer this critical early intervention, providing a shield against the uncertainties of the legal process and striving for the best possible outcome from the start.
We can help you determine how long the government has to charge a felony or misdemeanor and if there is a way to get all charges dismissed.
The attorneys on the LEWIS & DICKSTEIN Defense Team have decades of experience handling every type of criminal case. We routinely pursue constitutional challenges to charges and evidence. If there is a way to get your charges thrown out of court or get illegally obtained evidence suppressed, we will find it! If you have questions on any criminal legal matter, call us for a free consultation. When you hire us to defend you, you can expect the following from our team:
- Expert knowledge of constitutional law and criminal procedure
- Experience in handling suppression motions and evidentiary hearings
- Strong analytical and strategic thinking abilities
- Aggressiveness in defending clients’ rights
- Excellent oral advocacy and negotiation skills
- A track record of success in criminal defense
- Persistence and determination
- Ability to work under pressure and handle complex cases
- High ethical standards and professional integrity
- Compassion and understanding of clients’ situations
Call us today at (248) 263-6800 for a free consultation or complete an online Request for Assistance Form. We will contact you promptly and find a way to help you.
We will find a way to help you.
We Are Not Afraid to Win!
