Even the Innocent are at Risk of Conviction

The American justice system is one of the best in the world, but it is not perfect. Innocent men and women are charged in court and sometimes convicted, even if they are innocent.

An Example of Injustice in the American Judicial System

In 1984, when only 15 years old, mentally challenged, Anthony Caravella was taken into custody for allegedly stealing a bike. While he was in police custody, two police officers coerced Anthony into confessing to the rape and murder of a 58-year-old woman. Anthony was convicted and sentenced to life in prison, but DNA was later used to reverse his conviction.

In 2001, Caravella’s brother contacted a local newspaper and requested it to investigate Anthony’s predicament. The newspaper found some problems with the case and urged local authorities to re-examine the evidence. Eventually, Anthony’s conviction was overturned by DNA evidence – after 26 years in prison!!

A lawsuit was filed against the police officers who coerced Anthony into confessing, and a civil jury awarded Anthony $7 million.

The DNA used to reverse Anthony’s conviction was linked to another man, Anthony Martinez, for the rape and murder. Martinez was only 17 at the time. He died two months after being named a “person of interest.”

People are Wrongfully Convicted All the time.

Even with advanced DNA technology, the criminal justice system is far from perfect. People get wrongfully convicted all the time or convicted of charges based on false evidence or allegations. That is why a person facing criminal charges must have the best trial lawyer available. When your freedom is at stake, that is not the time to scrimp on an attorney. If facing life or death surgery, you want the best surgeon available. It is the same idea. Attorney fees should be reasonable and affordable, but a good lawyer will command a commensurate with his experience, reputation, and success in court. Like new DNA technology, you do not want to rely on future science to reverse your conviction. It is better to build a robust and effective defense the first time.

Don’t Trust Your Future to the Lowest Bidder

There are thousands of attorneys in Michigan. Many lawyers are general practitioners, meaning they practice in many different areas of the law (and specialize in none of them). Many new lawyers are trying to establish themselves. Countless criminal defense attorneys are known to plead their clients guilty without a fight, so prosecutors and judges do not take them seriously. The point is that the choices for a trial attorney vary in experience and cost. There is a reason for the cliche: “You get what you pay for.” An experienced trial lawyer will protect you, and sometimes the better question is, “How much will it cost NOT to hire an outstanding criminal defense attorney.”

By Hiring a Top Criminal Defense Attorney, Someone Might Not Have to Use DNA to Reverse a Conviction

In the complex and often daunting world of criminal defense, the role of a skilled attorney cannot be overstated. One of the most significant benefits of hiring a top criminal defense attorney lies in their ability to proactively address and potentially mitigate issues before they result in a wrongful conviction – an outcome that, in some cases, might only be reversed through post-conviction DNA testing.

The journey to reverse a wrongful conviction is long, arduous, and fraught with legal hurdles. It typically involves navigating a labyrinth of appeals and, in many instances, relying on the availability and viability of DNA evidence to prove innocence. This process can take years, if not decades, and is an emotional and financial strain not just on the convicted individual, but also on their loved ones. However, the proactive intervention of a highly competent criminal defense attorney can often prevent this heart-wrenching scenario.

Firstly, a top criminal defense lawyer brings an in-depth understanding of the law and an awareness of the latest legal precedents and technological advancements, including DNA evidence and other forensic methods. This expertise allows them to challenge the prosecution’s case more effectively and present a stronger defense from the outset. In cases where DNA evidence is relevant, they can ensure that it is appropriately analyzed, interpreted, and used strategically to bolster the defense.

Secondly, experienced attorneys excel in scrutinizing the evidence presented by the prosecution. They rigorously investigate every aspect of the case, often uncovering crucial details or discrepancies that can significantly impact the outcome. This meticulous approach can lead to the early dismissal of charges or a more favorable plea bargain, thus avoiding the need for a lengthy trial and the possibility of a wrongful conviction.

Thirdly, a top criminal defense attorney has the skills to communicate and negotiate effectively. They know how to articulate their client’s case persuasively, both in and out of the courtroom. Through skilled negotiation, they may be able to resolve the case favorably without resorting to a trial, where the outcome is always uncertain.

Additionally, an exceptional defense attorney’s emotional and psychological support should not be underestimated. Facing criminal charges is a highly stressful experience, and a supportive attorney can make a significant difference in helping clients navigate this challenging time.

In conclusion, while DNA evidence has become a crucial tool in reversing wrongful convictions, the goal should always be to prevent these injustices in the first place. By hiring a top criminal defense attorney, individuals accused of a crime can significantly increase their chances of a favorable outcome from the start. This proactive approach not only protects the rights of the accused but also serves the interests of justice, ensuring that the legal system functions as intended – to convict the guilty and protect the innocent.

Michigan trial attorneys with a reputation for success

When a person is facing criminal charges or being investigated for a possible crime, their interests must be protected right from the beginning. The trial attorneys with LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. often can stop charges from being brought in the first place. We are not afraid to win and have a reputation of respect and results. Our trial lawyers have handled criminal law matters throughout Michigan. Protecting people charged with crimes, or being investigated for crimes, is all we do. Our attorneys are well respected, experienced specialists in defending people against the tremendous power of the government. Call us for a free consultation. We will take the time to talk with you, answer your questions, and work with you to develop a winning defense.

Call us today at (248) 263-6800 for a free consultation or complete an online Request for Assistance Form. We will contact you promptly and find a way to help you.