Restitution Lawyers in Michigan Can Use the Law to Help You

While many lawyers fail even to consider the issue of restitution while defending a client, the Defense Team with LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. recognize that an excessive order for restitution can set the defendant up for failure. Our lawyers fight every issue to help our clients.

Restitution is Mandatory, But Excessive Restitution is Not

The case of Johnson v United States will decide the issue of whether restitution imposed on a criminal defendant is a criminal penalty subject to the requirements of the 6th Amendment to the United States Constitution that the government alleges in an indictment and prove beyond a reasonable doubt any fact that increases the severity of criminal sentences, penalties, and punishments. Restitution lawyers in Michigan will know how to turn the tables on the government and give the client an advantage in court.

What is Restitution, and Why Worry About it?

Restitution is ordered by the court as part of a criminal sentence. The intent is to force a convicted person to reimburse the victim for the damages suffered due to the convicted person’s actions. Restitution is routinely ordered at sentencing in criminal cases. The reason to be concerned is the prosecutor often provides the only documents that courts have to set the restitution amount. It is not hard to believe that a prosecutor or victim will inflate the dollar values to suit their purposes. Many courts believe that restitution is owed for life, and jail can be imposed to enforce payment. Restitution is not discharged in bankruptcy. Having top restitution lawyers in Michigan is essential because a restitution award lasts forever, and failure to make timely payments can result in jail time.

Right to a Hearing Regarding Restitution Amount

A defendant has the right to contest the amount allegedly owed for restitution. The fact that the restitution amount is disputed must be raised at sentencing, or the challenge is considered waived by the defendant. The prosecutor has the burden of proof to show the amount is correct. The standard is by a preponderance of the evidence. This means that a party has shown that its version of facts, causes, damages, or fault is more likely than not the correct version. Preponderance is the lowest level of proof. There is also no right to a jury, and the rules of evidence do not apply. It seems like the entire thing is stacked in favor of the prosecutor…..it is. You need the best restitution lawyers in Michigan in your corner to help balance the scales or tip them in your favor!

Profiteering Victims Seek Excessive Restitution Awards

In criminal cases, restitution is designed to compensate victims for their actual losses or damages directly caused by the crime. However, there are instances where victims might attempt to manipulate the restitution process to profit from the defendant, rather than simply recouping their losses. This manipulation can take various forms, and restitution lawyers in Michigan must be vigilant against those seeking to take advantage of their clients.

Victims might exaggerate the extent or value of their loss or damage. For example, in cases involving stolen or damaged property, they might claim a higher value than the property’s actual worth or overstate the extent of the damage. Additionally, victims could include losses not directly related to the criminal act, effectively seeking compensation for issues that existed before or were unrelated to the crime. There’s also the possibility of attempting to receive double compensation by seeking restitution for losses already covered by insurance payments or other means. In some cases, the emotional impact of the crime might be overstated to increase the restitution amount. While these situations aren’t the norm, and most victims seek restitution as a rightful part of their recovery, the legal system needs to scrutinize restitution claims to ensure fairness and prevent potential abuse.

Experienced Restitution Attorneys in Michigan

The fact that the United States Supreme Court is considering modifying restitution requirements is very pro-defendant. Prioritizing fairness is a GREAT THING. However, in the meantime, we must be aware of the current law and know that it is imperative that you have someone on your side protecting you from a runaway restitution award.

The elite but affordable restitution lawyers in Michigan from LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. can help you. Our attorneys will do whatever is necessary to ensure that any restitution ordered to be paid is the least amount possible. We do not believe in taking the prosecutor’s information at face value. Many attorneys consider restitution a given that cannot be contested. This is not true. With the proper preparation and legal counsel, there is a high likelihood of success at a restitution hearing. LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. is proud of its record for success and its reputation for not being afraid to win.

Call us today at (248) 263-6800 for a free consultation or complete an online Request for Assistance Form. We will contact you promptly and find a way to help you.